ANALYSIS: Can Eskom blame the ‘coldest winter in 10 years’ for load shedding?
Did the “coldest winter in 10 years” trigger electrical energy blackouts in South Africa? That’s the declare by André de Ruyter, CEO of public electrical energy utility Eskom.
In a current interview on SAfm’s Market Replace, host Nompu Siziba requested De Ruyter why, when financial exercise was restricted by the Covid-19 lockdown, the nation’s lights went out.
“South Africa skilled the coldest winter in 10 years, and through these chilly snaps demand exceeded what we had anticipated, even earlier than lockdown started,” he responded.
“So, whereas total financial exercise was decrease, the peaks that we skilled due to excessive demand as a result of chilly climate definitely exceeded expectations and put further pressure on our system. And that regrettably led to load shedding.”
However did South Africa actually have its “coldest winter in 10 years”?
Load shedding in 2020
Eskom says it makes use of load shedding – scheduled electrical energy blackouts – to “stop the collapse of the ability system country-wide”.
“When energy is inadequate, Eskom can thus both enhance provide or cut back demand to deliver the system again into stability,” it explains. “By switching off components of the community in a deliberate and managed method, the system stays secure all through the day, and the impression is unfold over a wider base of consumers.”
The EskomSePush telephone app alerts customers to scheduled blackouts in South Africa, and has a file of every day energy outages since 2015.
It reveals there have been 29 days of load shedding within the first three months of 2020. There was no load shedding in April, Could and June. The facility went out once more in July, for seven days. In August there have been 5 days of load shedding, and one other six in September. There was no load shedding in October.
No response from Eskom
Dr Liesl Dyson, a meteorologist within the College of Pretoria’s division of geography, geoinformatics and meteorology, and Dr Christien Engelbrecht, a senior researcher on the South African Climate Service, helped Africa Examine fact-check De Ruyter’s declare.
“We aren’t conscious what knowledge Eskom’s CEO used when stating that South African skilled the coldest winter in 10 years,” they wrote in a report. “One ought to be aware that Eskom has their very own community of statement stations and it could be that this knowledge was analysed.”
Africa Examine emailed Eskom’s media desk to ask for the supply of De Ruyter’s knowledge, and the way it was calculated. We additionally phoned all three of the numbers offered to the media. Now we have not but obtained any response. (Observe: We’ll replace this report ought to we achieve this.)
Under regular temperatures in August
Dyson and Engelbrecht consulted international unified temperature knowledge from the Local weather Prediction Centre. It is a subdivision of the Nationwide Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, a scientific company inside america Division of Commerce that focuses on the circumstances of the oceans and environment.
Utilizing this knowledge they calculated the typical most and minimal month-to-month temperatures within the south western Cape, south coast, Northern Cape and highveld in 2020.
These have been in comparison with the latest “local weather normals” for the area, for 1981 to 2010. It is a calculation of the “regular temperatures” anticipated in South Africa every month primarily based on 30 years of information.
Most temp ‘beneath regular’ in August
Dyson and Engelbrecht discovered that “most temperatures over South Africa have been usually above regular” for Could to July. Nevertheless, Gauteng, Mpumalanga and Limpopo recorded beneath regular most temperatures in June and July.
In August most temperatures have been beneath regular within the western and central inside of the nation. South Africa’s excessive east skilled beneath regular temperatures in September.
Winter months ‘beneath regular’ temperature
Minimal temperatures have been discovered to be “usually beneath regular” for all winter months.
“In August all the nation skilled beneath regular minimal temperatures and within the Free State and Jap Cape temperatures have been as a lot as 5 levels Celsius beneath regular,” Dyson and Engelbrecht wrote.
“As minimal temperatures often happen near dawn, the beneath regular temperatures throughout this time could very conceivably [have] resulted in elevated electrical energy demand through the morning peak intervals.
“Though the temperatures have been usually beneath regular in these 4 areas in August, it is just within the Northern Cape the place minimal temperatures in August have been the bottom up to now 10 years.”
Winter not coldest in 10 years
However the temperature knowledge doesn’t present that the nation had the “coldest winter in 10 years”, as De Ruyter claimed. Dyson and Engelbrecht additionally analysed the three months of winter (June, July and August) as one unit.
“[D]uring the winter interval there have been chilly occasions, which resulted in beneath regular temperatures for shorter intervals. On the whole for the three months of winter temperatures remained regular to above regular.”
Dyson and Engelbrecht mentioned the findings of their evaluation ought to be interpreted cautiously as totally different timeframes and geographical areas of research may affect the outcomes.
“A extra thorough evaluation is required to attract decisive conclusions.”
‘Blaming the climate is like blaming God’
Chris Yelland, an engineer and analyst at vitality consulting agency EE Enterprise Intelligence in Johannesburg, informed Africa Examine there was a hyperlink between chilly climate and a rise in vitality demand in winter. However he mentioned this occurs everywhere in the world.
“[There is] nothing uncommon a couple of chilly snap. Now we have chilly climate yearly. When you may have a chilly snap, one doesn’t count on the system to fall over. The entire energy system can’t be dependent simply on the climate,” mentioned Yelland. “It’s simply not adequate. It’s disingenuous. Blaming the climate is like blaming God.”
Prof Anton Eberhard from the College of Cape City’s Graduate College of Enterprise mentioned: “The primary reason behind the load shedding is the deterioration within the efficiency of Eskom’s energy technology plant and the lateness in procuring new impartial energy producers.
“The chilly winter interval definitely will increase electrical energy demand and locations further pressure on the system however South Africa ought to have had adequate analysis capability to deal with these demand peaks.”
Elsabé Brits is a contract science and medical reporter from South Africa. Observe her at @elsabebrits.
© Copyright Africa Examine 2020. Learn our republishing pointers. You could reproduce this piece or content material from it for the aim of reporting and/or discussing information and present occasions. That is topic to: Crediting Africa Examine within the byline, conserving all hyperlinks to the sources used and including this sentence on the finish of your publication: “This report was written by Africa Examine, a non-partisan fact-checking organisation. View the unique piece on their web site”, with a hyperlink again to this web page.