ANALYSIS: A conflict of science and custom in Nigeria’s healthcare sector
Want a “answer” for miscarriage? Attain for the amaranth plant. Affected by rheumatoid arthritis? A paste of mango bark and onion ought to do the trick. Hepatitis B? No fear, drink a mixture of herbs, spices and camel urine. Your youngster having convulsions? A mixture of onion, ginger, garlic and oil will finish them. Then there’s the natural treatment for the coronavirus from Madagascar that captured the continent’s consideration.
In our fact-checking work in Nigeria, we come throughout scores of those remedies yearly.
We continuously debunk these unproven cures however they proceed to proliferate, enthusiastically acquired on social media, maybe reflecting Nigerians’ robust perception in conventional drugs. Some say it’s an enormous business within the continent’s most populous nation.
But once we ask consultants in orthodox drugs, their reply is unfailing – disregard these remedies as they’re unproven and, in some situations, may develop into downright harmful.
State businesses such because the Nigeria Centre for Illness Management additionally usually advise folks to depend on recommendation from well being consultants.
Given the scepticism, is there a conflict of tradition between the 2 approaches? And is the hole unbridgeable?
Faster and cheaper remedies
The World Well being Group defines traditional drugs because the “information and practices primarily based on theories, beliefs and experiences indigenous to completely different cultures, used within the upkeep of well being”.
In lots of nations additionally it is often called different or complementary drugs, the worldwide well being company says. The commonest components are herbs, with as many as 80% in Africa having used these strategies for his or her main care.
On-line, these different approaches are provided as faster and cheaper remedies for a wide range of illnesses and life-threatening ailments.
We requested medical practitioners in Nigeria to inform us their core issues about conventional medicines.
A number of the risks embody the dearth of standardisation on dosage and frequency of use, Oyewale Tomori, a professor of virology, advised Africa Test.
There may be additionally usually little details about the components utilized in them or an understanding of their operate, Tomori, who can be a former vice-chancellor of the Redeemer’s College in south-western Nigeria, added.
Marycelin Baba is a professor of medical virology and microbiology on the College of Maiduguri in northern Nigeria. She advised Africa Test that conventional drugs mixed crops that had not been subjected to analysis, which might be harmful.
“Not all crops will be mixed or consumed,” she stated. “Some are poisonous and might result in loss of life. Earlier than anybody comes out with a declare a few combination serving as a therapy, it should be completely researched and examined.”
Cultural acceptance and weak well being methods
Given these vital shortcomings, why does different drugs thrive in Nigeria?
Prof Tanimola Akande is a public well being doctor on the College of Ilorin Educating Hospital. He stated some causes for the enduring perception in different drugs have been cultural acceptability, poor and weak well being methods that made entry to orthodox drugs difficult, and the unregulated promotion of conventional drugs by practitioners.
Oladimeji Okunola, a principal nutritionist, agreed that the excessive value of high quality healthcare was an element. Accessing correct medical care in Nigeria was not low-cost, he stated, as public healthcare was weak and, for instance, lacked tools. Many Nigerians are subsequently pressured to think about personal hospitals, which in lots of situations have greater prices.
And authorities hospitals are overcrowded and underfunded. “There are extra sufferers and fewer docs or specialists. One must ebook prematurely simply to see a specialist. If one doesn’t need to battle with these elements and extra, the subsequent possibility is conventional drugs, which is a lot cheaper.”
Public figures additionally fan the expansion of conventional drugs. In April 2020, Oyo state governor Seyi Makinde revealed that he fought Covid-19 by taking vitamin C and black seed oil blended with honey.
An unregulated business
Akande has additionally chaired the Affiliation of Public Well being Physicians of Nigeria. He confirmed there was a battle between science-based and conventional drugs.
In his view, the recognition of unproven remedies might be doing extra hurt than good to Nigerians’ well being. “A excessive stage of problems ensuing from conventional drugs is seen in orthodox drugs and most current too late for significant treatments,” he advised Africa Test.
“Conventional drugs in Nigeria has a lot secrecy and [practitioners] don’t topic their merchandise to scientific analysis for proof of efficacy.”
Regulation would assist. “The present scenario the place anybody can declare they’re conventional practitioners just isn’t useful to the well being system since that is prone to abuse and quackery.”
Bringing science and custom collectively
However conventional drugs had a task in medical care, each in Nigeria and elsewhere on the earth, Akande stated. Some are derived from herbs, and have medicinal worth.
So how can the 2 approaches be introduced nearer collectively?
“The hole will be bridged if conventional drugs is able to topic its merchandise for verification of efficacy,” Akande stated. This is able to assist refine them and outline a normal dosage.
“Conventional drugs ought to develop to a stage the place practitioners will be licensed to practise primarily based on their information and expertise or coaching.”
Olayinka Karim is a professor of meals science and know-how on the school of agriculture on the College of Ilorin. She has researched plant meals processing utilizing conventional strategies.
She agreed that there might be a more in-depth relationship between science and conventional drugs.
“Conventional drugs depends on natural-based supplies akin to extracts from meals. These extracts include phytochemicals which can be helpful to the physique. The problem with the medicines is that the processes used to arrange remedies could not conform to some requirements. Some elements they use usually are not refined. Additionally they lack information of the dosage.”
The best way ahead was orientation, Karim stated. Conventional sellers ought to be educated on trendy therapy strategies.
“The pharmaceutical sector ought to step in to enlighten them on dosage, high quality and amount of elements,” she stated. Practitioners must also be taught to detect and mitigate the unintended effects of their components.
A task for secure conventional drugs – WHO
The WHO says as a result of as much as a 3rd of the inhabitants in Africa lacks entry to important medicines, “the availability of secure and efficient conventional and different treatments may change into an essential approach of accelerating entry to well being care companies”.
The company has stated it “recognises that conventional, complementary and different drugs has many advantages and Africa has a protracted historical past of conventional drugs and practitioners”.
“Africans deserve to make use of medicines examined to the identical requirements as folks in the remainder of the world. Even when therapies are derived from conventional follow and pure, establishing their efficacy and security via rigorous medical trials is important.”
It seems that till that is executed the chasm between orthodox and conventional drugs will stay a yawning one.
© Copyright Africa Test 2020. Learn our republishing pointers. You could reproduce this piece or content material from it for the aim of reporting and/or discussing information and present occasions. That is topic to: Crediting Africa Test within the byline, holding all hyperlinks to the sources used and including this sentence on the finish of your publication: “This report was written by Africa Test, a non-partisan fact-checking organisation. View the unique piece on their web site”, with a hyperlink again to this web page.